No birthday gifts from 4 star friends.

[zielonaofwildwood]

Glimmer (4 stars) did not give me a birthday gift! Is this luck or a bug? Almost every other cat gave me a gift. Phantom (4 stars) did not, but I gave them a gift first, so I think that might be it. Zephyr and Garlic (both 2 stars) are the same. Do cats not give you a gift if you gift them before talking to them on your birthday? And why did Glimmer not give me a gift even though every cat acknowledged my birthday?

I am on PC with fully updated Windows laptop. I have encountered glitches before.

[Agrith Dragonflame]

I'm not entirely sure, but I believe it is still a chance based thing whether they give one or not. They just have a much higher chance to give you one on your birthday. Either that, or it is a bug. I know I haven't gotten one sometimes myself.

[condemnedtoaschoolcomputer]

For one, I think cats only give gifts if they are three stars or higher.